Broker Check

WEEKLY MARKET COMMENTARY | FEBRUARY 24, 2022

February 24, 2022
Share |

Special Edition: The Russian Invasion of Ukraine and Your Portfolio

Q&A: How the Russian Invasion of Ukraine May Affect Investors

On Thursday, February 24, after months of tension and military buildup, Russia invaded Ukraine. It's the first major war between European nations in decades and brings significant humanitarian and economic ramifications for the entire world.

I want to assure you that my team and I have spent a lot of time analyzing the situation and how it might impact you. We'll go over some of the details in a moment, but the most important thing for you to know is that we are keeping a close eye on everything. We remain confident in our investment strategy as well as the path to your financial goals. 

Now, as you can imagine, the markets fell sharply when the world woke up to the news of the invasion. By the close of the day, though, markets were up on average about 1.75%, indicating that investors often dislike uncertainty – in this case, the potential for an invasion, more than they dislike bad news – the invasion itself.

In this message, I will explain what effect this war is likely to have on both the global economy and the markets. Because I'm a financial advisor, not a geopolitical expert or military strategist, I'm going to refrain from commenting on why this war is happening, even though I have my own opinions, as I'm sure you do. Before continuing, though, I do want to say that my heart goes out to the Ukrainian people. While this message will focus on war's financial and economic consequences, nothing compares to the human cost. I earnestly hope that peace prevails as soon as possible. 

Now, let's do a Q&A about how this conflict will impact investors. These are some of the most common questions I've heard from clients over the past few days. 

Q: Why is this conflict impacting the markets? 

A: You've undoubtedly noticed in recent weeks how volatile the markets have been. The ultimate reason, frankly, is quite simple. War brings disruption. To production, to trade, to everything. 

That's especially true with this conflict. Russia and Ukraine are key players when it comes to the global economy. For example, both together comprise 29% of the world's wheat.1  Ukraine alone is one of the world's top producers of corn, while Russia is Europe's largest source of both oil and natural gas. Both countries also play a significant role in producing minerals and metals – copper, nickel, platinum, etc. 

These are not products the world can live without. From the U.S. to China, from Germany to Ghana, we depend on these products to eat, communicate, get to work, grow crops, and even stay warm. If you think of the global economy as a big spider web, touching a strand on one end causes the entire web to vibrate – sometimes violently. 

Now, both Europe and the United States can take steps to mitigate these issues. (More on that in a moment.)  But given that we are still recovering from supply disruptions caused by the pandemic, war is the last thing the world needs right now. 

Another reason this conflict impacts the markets is because of the shock it will have on the global financial system – in the form of economic sanctions the West has started levying on Russia. 

Q: What are the U.S. and European Union doing about this?

A: Before we get into what the U.S. is doing, let's quickly cover what the U.S. is not. 

This is not a war between the United States and Russia. Currently, there are no plans to send U.S. troops into Ukraine.2  While American forces have reinforced several nearby countries like Poland and Romania, these are fellow NATO members. Ukraine is not a member of NATO, which means the terms of its alliance do not bind NATO to defend it from invasion. Instead, the U.S. will support Ukraine by providing supplies, intelligence, and logistical assistance. 

Because Russia's actions are both a violation of international law and its own pledge to respect Ukraine's borders3, the U.S. and many other western countries have announced a number of economic sanctions.4 Some of these sanctions include:

  • Asset freezes and travel bans on dozens of influential Russian politicians and business leaders.
  • Restricting Russia's access to the European Union's financial markets.
  • Halting construction of the undersea Nord Stream 2 pipeline, which was set to deliver natural gas to Germany and be a major source of new business for Russia.
  • Barring Russian banks from raising money in the west or trading new debt in U.S. or European markets.

According to President Biden, these sanctions are just the first wave, with more soon to come.

Now, there's no question that sanctions will have a major impact on Russia's economy. When Russia forcibly annexed Crimea in 2014, the U.S. also imposed sanctions on Russia that many experts believe have dramatically stalled Russia's economic growth. (Since 2014, Russia's economy has grown by an average of 0.3% per year, compared to the global average of 2.3%.5)  These new sanctions are likely to be even greater, with an even more significant effect. 

But sanctions take time and alone won't stop Russian forces from penetrating Ukraine. They can also be a double-edged sword. 

Since World War II, Europe has become more economically intertwined to prevent another devastating conflict. (This idea was the impetus behind the European Union.)  Since the end of the Cold War, Europe has also worked to make Russia a more integral economic partner. The idea was that the more East and West relied on each other for trade, the less likely war would ever break out. 

While this experiment has largely been successful, there's a downside. Trade in times of peace brings mutual gain – but nixing trade brings mutual pain. Sanctions will undoubtedly punish Russian banks and companies that depend on foreign business. But it can also hurt U.S. and European firms that rely on business with Russia, another reason the war is roiling the stock market. 

Q: Okay, so let's focus on what's happening here at home. How long will market volatility last because of this? 

Obviously, that's impossible to say. Furthermore, trying to guess – and then making decisions based on a guess – is one of the worst things we as investors can do.

That said, there are some interesting things to note here. First is that, historically, geopolitical crises often have a surprisingly short-lived effect on the markets. For example, take the Cuban Missile Crisis. The world has never been closer to nuclear war than during those nerve-wracking thirteen days in 1962, yet during that time, the Dow only fell 1.2%. By the end of the year, the Dow was up 10%.6 

Remember when Iraq invaded Kuwait back in 1990? The Dow declined more than 18% in the immediate aftermath – only to recover completely a few months later and indeed climb 38% over the next two years.7  Eleven years later, after the September 11 attacks, the Dow fell over 14% but returned to normal a few months later. 7   More recently, look at Brexit. When the U.K. voted to leave the European Union, it took most analysts by surprise, and many predicted it would lead to a major drop in the markets. At first, it did. The vote took place on a Thursday. The next day, the Dow fell over 600 points and another 250 points the Monday after.8  But less than a month later, the Dow climbed to a new record high. 

As you can see, while geopolitical events often seem scary to investors, their impact on the markets isn't necessarily huge. That's because many things impact the markets. Even something as big as war is only one ingredient in the dish. 

On the other hand, financial experts like to say that "Past performance is no guarantee of future results." So, just because history has leaned one way doesn't mean it can't shift course in the future. This current crisis could have a sustained impact on the markets for all the reasons we've discussed. There's no way to know – meaning we need to be mentally and emotionally prepared for both possibilities.

Another thing we need to prepare for is the possibility of higher prices here at home. 

Q: So, how will this war affect our own economy? 

There's no point beating around the bush: Consumer prices are already sky-high and are now likely to rise even higher. 

Due to the pandemic, inflation has risen at a historic rate. New sanctions and supply-chain issues will only compound the problem. For that reason, it's possible we'll see a jump in prices for the following goods and commodities:

  • While oil prices and the price we pay at the pump aren't the same, they are linked. On February 24 alone, oil prices rose above $100 per barrel.9
  • Natural gas. As of this writing, prices are up 29% in Europe; we could see a similar rise.10
  • Travel costs. Pricier oil means pricier jet fuel, which means higher airfares for travelers.
  • As we've already covered, Russia and Ukraine are hugely important to the world's supply of wheat, corn, and other staples.
  • From your car to your cell phone, we rely on minerals and metals for our technology to function. Due to the pandemic, there was already a shortage of these supplies.

The U.S. can release oil reserves to combat rising fuel prices, and Europe can turn to other places for natural gas and wheat. (Including the United States.)  But while these measures can help, they'll take time – and can only blunt a rise in consumer prices, not stop it entirely. 

Interest rates may also be affected. Most experts expected the Federal Reserve would soon announce significant rate hikes to combat inflation. In light of the invasion, interest rates will probably still go up but maybe less than previously thought. That's good news for the stock market, at least in the short term, but it won't help slow inflation as much.

Q: Given everything that's going on, what should we be doing about it? 

Before today, the idea of one European country invading another seemed almost unthinkable. It was something for the history books, not the front page. But that's the world we woke up to today. A different world than the one we went to sleep in yesterday. 

But here's the thing to remember – the world is always changing – and we've always done a great job of adapting.

The situation in Ukraine will likely change every day, hour, and even minute. Headlines you read in the morning might be obsolete by afternoon. That's why it makes no sense trying to parse each and every one. When we do that, all we're really doing is making an emotional decision based on an emotional reaction. Our strategy removes emotion from the process so we can make clear, rational decisions. So, while the headlines might seem scary, I hope you take comfort in the fact that we can adapt to changing market conditions with great agility, all based on your needs and goals. 

I hope you found this message to be informative. Of course, please let me know if you have any questions or concerns about your portfolio. My team and I are here for you. We'll keep monitoring the situation, and whenever a change is warranted, we'll let you know immediately.  

Sincerely yours,


Greg Clifton, ChFC, CFP®, MBA


Securities offered through Registered Representatives of Cambridge Investment Research, Inc., a broker-dealer, member FINRA/SIPC. Advisory services offered through Cambridge Investment Research Advisors, Inc., a Registered Investment Advisor. Clifton Capital Advisors, LLC and Cambridge are not affiliated.

* This newsletter was prepared by Bill Good Marketing. Bill Good Marketing is not affiliated with the named firm or broker/dealer.

Sources

1 "How a Russian invasion of Ukraine could hit supply chains," CNBC, February 23, 2022. https://www.cnbc.com/2022/02/23/impact-of-russia-ukraine-on-supply-chains-food-metals-commodities.html

2 "Here's what Biden has said about sending U.S. troops to Ukraine," CNN, February 24, 2022. https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/24/politics/us-troops-ukraine-russia-nato/index.html

3 "Letter from the Permanent Representatives of the Russian Federation…to the United Nations," General Assembly Security Council, December 19, 1994. http://www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/s_1994_1399.pdf

4 "U.S. imposes sanctions on Russian banks, sovereign debt and elites after Ukraine invasion," Politico, February 22, 2024. https://www.politico.com/news/2022/02/22/u-s-sanctions-russia-ukraine-invasion-00010733

5 "The impact of Western sanctions on Russia," The Atlantic Council, May 3, 2021. https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/in-depth-research-reports/report/the-impact-of-western-sanctions-on-russia/

6 "How markets reacted to geopolitical crises," The Economic Times, April 13, 2017. http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/stocks/news/how-markets-reacted-to-geopolitical-crises/articleshow/58158842.cms

7 "Stock Market History: More Ups Than Downs," Forbes, September 27, 2017. https://www.forbes.com/sites/johndobosz/2017/09/20/stock-market-history-more-ups-than-downs/?sh=71324c093951

8 "Dow plunges over 600 points as U.K.' earthquake' crushes global markets," CNN Money, June 24, 2016. http://money.cnn.com/2016/06/23/investing/eu-referendum-markets/index.html?iid=EL

9 "Global oil prices soar above $100 and could go much higher," CNN Business, February 24, 2022. https://edition.cnn.com/2022/02/23/business/brent-oil-ukraine-russia/index.html

10 "Russia's attack on Ukraine means these prices are going even higher," CNN Business, February 24, 2022. https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/24/business/inflation-russia-ukraine-explainer/index.html